Caravaggio, a mandolin, and the year the art video went to number four.
The song was an accident — Peter Buck teaching himself mandolin in front of the television, a circular figure that stuck — and the video was the opposite: composed to the frame. Tarsem Singh, an Indian-born director, built R.E.M.'s first global hit out of paintings. The light is Caravaggio's, hard and warm and falling from one side; the tableaux include Saint Sebastian and a winged man fallen to earth; Michael Stipe performs the lyric in small obsessive gestures, reaching and repeating, in a room that looks like it was painted rather than lit. Singh has said the imagery came partly from García Márquez's A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings, and the video reads like that story: something miraculous has landed in a village, and the village doesn't know what to do with it.
It swept the 1991 VMAs — six awards including Video of the Year and Best Direction — and took the Grammy the following February. It sits at #1 because it is where the two halves of this list meet: a video with a visual language borrowed from painting, made for a band from the college-rock circuit, that reached number four in the US and heavy rotation everywhere. Everything that follows — Fincher's black-and-white Madonna, Jonze's fake cop show, Dayton and Faris's Méliès — happens inside the permission this clip established: that a music video could be authored, look like art, and still be the most-played thing on the channel. Singh went on to features (The Cell, The Fall); R.E.M. return at #15 with a video that cost the Beastie Boys a Moonman.